Cleveland Indians Index Page

←

HOME

Cleveland Indians Pages By Decade

1900

1910

1920

1930

1940

1950

1960

1970

1980

1990

2000

2010

2020

Cleveland Indians All Time Team Player Pages

First Team

Second Team

Third Team

Fourth Team

Fifth Team

Sixth Team

Pos

Player

Cleveland Tenure

WAR/Pts

Player

Cleveland Tenure

WAR/Pts

Player

Cleveland Tenure

WAR/Pts

Player

Cleveland Tenure

WAR/Pts

Player

Cleveland Tenure

WAR/Pts

Player

Cleveland Tenure

WAR/Pts

Catcher

Steve O'Neill

1912-1923

23.23 / 73

Carlos Santana

2010-2020

29.52 / 72

Jim Hegan

1946-1957

4.74 / 63

Victor Martinez

2004-2009

19.25 / 52

Sandy Alomar

1990-2000

13.32 / 49

John Romano

1960-1964

14.62 / 48

First Base

Jim Thome

1992-2002

48.01 / 86

Hal Trosky

1934-1941

29.85 / 72

Andre Thornton

1977-1986

19.05/ 58

George Burns

1921-1928

13.86 / 44

Mike Hargrove

1979-1985

14 / 44

Travis Hafner

2003-2012

24.97 / 43

Second Base

Nap Lajoie

1902-1914

79.93 / 149

Ray Chapman

1912-1920

29.08 / 86

Bobby Avila

1950-1958

27.88 / 73

Julio Franco

1983-1988

17.36 / 56

Odell Hale

1933-1939

16.16 / 52

Jason Kipnis

2011-2019

22.46 / 51

ShortStop

Lou Boudreau

1939-1950

61.67 / 117

Joe Sewell

1920-1930

45.58 / 101

Francisco Lindor

2015-2020

29.66 / 77

Omar Vizquel

1994-2004

30.2 / 74

Woody Held

1958-1964

18.85 / 60

Asdrubal Cabrera

2007-2014

20.15 / 52

Third Base

Jose Ramirez

2015-2022

40.43 / 88

Al Rosen

1950-1956

32.6 / 84

Ken Keltner

1938-1949

33.78 / 73

Bill Bradley

1901-1910

35.2 / 63

Terry Turner

1904-1918

38.8 / 63

Buddy Bell

1972-1978

24.47 / 48

Outfield

Tris Speaker

1916-1926

74.24 / 173

Larry Doby

1948-1958

43.47 / 107

Jeff Heath

1938-1945

24.84 / 68

Manny Ramirez

1995-2000

29.96 / 62

Jack Graney

1910-1921

14.28 / 57

Shin-Soo Choo

2006-2012

21.78 / 53

Outfield

Earl Averill

1929-1938

47.91 / 132

Charlie Jamieson

1920-1930

23.9 / 77

Grady Sizemore

2004-2010

27.7 / 64

Rocky Colavito

1956-1967

22.91 / 58

Joe Vosmik

1931-1936

16.6 / 57

Michael Brantley

2009-2018

22.69 / 53

Outfield

Kenny Lofton

1992-2007

48.56 / 122

Elmer Flick

1902-1909

31.2 / 72

Shoeless Joe Jackson

1911-1915

34.95 / 64

Albert Belle

1991-1996

27.41 / 57

Rick Manning

1975-1983

11.68 / 54

Dale Mitchell

1947-1953

18.88 / 49

Starting Pitcher

Bob Feller

1936-1956

65.54 / 176

Early Wynn

1949-1957

36.09 / 107

Charles Nagy

1992-2001

24.99 / 86

CC Sabathia

2001-2008

27.6 / 76

Cliff Lee

2003-2009

16.23 / 57

Carlos Carrasco

2009-2020

21.91 / 51

Starting Pitcher

Bob Lemon

1946-1957

37.8 / 134

Addie Joss

1902-1910

46.48 / 106

Willis Hudlin

1927-1939

32.62 / 86

Wes Ferrell

1929-1933

30.75 / 72

Gaylord Perry

1972-1975

28.75 / 55

Bob Rhoads

1904-1909

12.53 / 49

Starting Pitcher

Mel Harder

1930-1947

48.69 / 125

Miguel Garcia

1949-1957

31.02 / 89

George Uhle

1919-1928

29.92 / 84

Cory Kluber

2012-2019

33.18 / 67

Earl Moore

1901-1905

15.18 / 53

Luis Tiant

1964-1969

26.25 / 49

Starting Pitcher

Stan Coveleski

1916-1924

55.43 / 110

Sam McDowell

1962-1971

42.61 / 88

Jim Bagby

1916-1922

29.11/ 78

Gary Bell

1958-1967

12.52 / 57

Guy Morton

1915-1923

19.17 / 51

Bill Bernhard

1902-1906

11.81 / 48

Relief Pitcher

Jose Mesa

1992-1998

10.4 / 43

Cody Allen

2013-2018

8.91 / 39

Doug Jones

1987-1991

10.72 / 35

Dennis Eckersley

1975-1977

13.34 / 29

Ray Narleski

1954-1958

12.51 / 26

Bob Wickman

2001-2006

5.51 / 26