Decade: The World War II Years (1940-1949)
Home Pages   1930's Decade Page 1950's Decade Page
 
Team Decade Pages (Average Win Shares / Points per year in decade): Top Team Builders In Decade:
AMERICAN LEAGUE: NATIONAL LEAGUE: 1 - Branch Rickey (GM) - Dodgers
New York Yankees - 121 St. Louis Cardinals - 125 2 - Branch Rickey (GM) - Cards
Boston Red Sox - 111 Brooklyn Dodgers - 116 3 - Ed Barrow (GM), George Weiss (Farm Director, GM) - Yankees
Detroit Tigers - 108 Cincinnati Reds - 100 4 - Larry MacPhail (GM), Leo Durocher (Manager) - Dodgers
Cleveland Indians - 105 Pittsburgh Pirates - 99 5 - Herb Pennock (GM) - Phillies
Chicago White Sox -92 Chicago Cubs - 96 6 - Billy Southworth (Manager), John Quinn (GM) - Braves
St. Louis Browns - 91 New York Giants - 95 7 - Bill Veeck Jr (Owner), Hank Greenberg (GM) - Cleveland
Washington Senators - 88 Boston Braves - 94 8 - Jack Zeller (GM) - Detroit
Philadelphia A's -  83 Philadelphia Phillies - 76 9 - Joe Cronin (Manger), Billy Evans (GM), Eddie Collins (GM) - Red Sox
    10 - Bill McKechnie (Manager), Larry MacPhail (GM). Powel Crosley (Owner) - Reds
 
Decade Highlights
 
   The backdrop for baseball the entire decade was World War II. Beginning with the 1942 season, the major leagues were losing all of their stars to the war. A number of executives also
enlisted such as GM Larry MacPhail of the Dodgers. It's hard to imagine in this day and age, privileged people going to war in this country. Back then, everybody went, rich or poor. 
The fact that the normalcy of baseball was continuing during the war was a great inspiration to many during those dark times.
Aside from MacPhail, other executives were also affected by the war. Powel Crosley of the Reds, whose teams just won the '39 and '40 pennants, completely lost interest in his ballclub
and concentrated on the war effort. There was an executive meeting of baseball owners scheduled for December 7th 1941 that was to be a vote on the Browns moving to Los Angeles.
Had the Browns moved to LA, the course of baseball history would have been radically changed. As it was, Pearl Harbor put the kibosh on that one and Browns owner Donald Barnes
was left reeling.
 
   From 1942 thru 1945, baseball was a diluted product, talent wise. By 1945, career minor leaguers were the stars. Of course, there was one executive who was ahead of the curve, twice. 
Seeing what was coming, Cards GM Branch Rickey was able to load up his club with 4F's. These were major league quality players who had a disability that precluded them from going
into the army. Not surprisingly, the Cards, a team of bonafide major leaguers, dominated in the period, winning titles in '42, '43 and '44.
 As if that wasn't enough, Rickey hired on as Dodgers GM in 1942 after Larry MacPhail had gone off to war. Rickey immediately began signing the very top youngsters out of high school to
contracts despite the uncertainty of their status with the war. Only one other GM, Herb Pennock of the Phillies was on Rickey's wavelength. This policy paid huge dividends as Brooklyn
signed future stars Gil Hodges, Duke Snider, Ralph Branca and Cal McLish that others were not persuing.
 
  The other huge happening in the Forties also involved Branch Rickey. The Dodgers broke the color line bringing Jackie Robinson to the Big Leagues in 1947. 
Rickey was a good Christian, but he was also a competitor. He was always looking for an edge and there were some great black ballplayers out there. Rickey had his pick of the litter.
Aside from Robinson, the Dodgers also signed ace righthander Don Newcombe and HOF catcher Roy Campanella before anybody knew what hit them. Other teams that followed suit
were the Indians, whose owner Bill Veeck was an exception to the mogul rule of baseball ownership. He was a man of the people and was truly colorblind. The New York Giants and the
Boston Braves also began signing black players early on. It's not surprising that all four clubs were at or near the top of the standings in the late Forties and early Fifties.
 
   1946 began Baseball's Golden Age. The war was over. Things were good for everybody in America. There was a huge middle class. Lots of vets getting inexpensive housing, inexpensive 
education, good jobs. Babies were booming. Nice time to be in America. Baseball was a part of the fabric of America. The Golden Age was golden in part because all three New York clubs 
were doing really well on the field. This meant lots of exposure to the sport, lots of media coverage.  
 
  The top team in the National League during the decade was the Cards with four pennants, three World Series titles, five second place finishes and a third place finish.  
St. Louis averaged a gaudy 96-58 mark. Brooklyn was the only other top NL team during the decade with three pennants, three seconds and three thirds.
 
  In the American League, it was the Yankees with five pennants and four World Series titles.  Detroit had two pennants and a World Series, Cleveland a World Series and Boston and the
Browns a pennant each. New York, Detroit, Cleveland and Boston were the top teams throughout the decade while the Browns had their one season in the sun in 1944, their only pennant
in St. Louis. Ironically, it was the Cards that beat them in the '44 World Series.
 
  Baseball was also a lot more balanced in the Forties. The Live Ball Era of the Twenties and Thirties was over. Not exactly clear why, but hitting was a couple of notches down. 
Maybe it was night baseball. Not only was the ball not as visible, but night baseball changed travel and player's routines. Hard to say, but there was a clear difference. 
You would think that with the lesser reliance on the home run, that teams would have ramped up manufacturing runs, going back to emphasizing speed. Not so. The only team
to emphasize running moving forward into the Golden Age was the Dodgers. And they were very successful. Yet nobody copied them.
 
Top Players In Decade Pages (Win Shares / Points and WAR (in parentheses) for Decade ):
   
All Positions -  Top 50 Top Starting Pitchers Top Catchers Top Outfielders
1 - Lou Boudreau Cleveland (59.86) - 114 2 - Hal Newhouser Detroit (54.87) - 113 43 - Walker Cooper Cards (19.08) - 65 3 - Ted Williams Boston (65.83) - 112
2 - Hal Newhouser Detroit (54.87) - 113 7 - Bob Feller Cleveland (38.65) - 100 Phil Masi Braves (12.59) - 50 4 - Stan Musial Cards (57.56) - 110
3 - Ted Williams Boston (65.83) - 112 12 - Bucky Walters Reds (28.59) - 92 Birdie Tebbetts Boston (4.13) - 48 5 - Joe DiMaggio Yankees (43.59) - 102
4 - Stan Musial Cards (57.56) - 110 13 - Dutch Leonard Washington (31.84) - 89 Ernie Lombardi Giants (19.16) - 46 8 -  Dominic DiMaggio Boston (24.73) - 98
5 - Joe DiMaggio Yankees (43.59) - 102 19 - Rip Sewell Pittburgh (25.12) - 83 15 - Tommy Holmes Braves (32.77) - 85
6 - Vern Stephens Browns (35.16) - 101 21 - Dizzy Trout Detroit  (37.62) - 79 Top First Basemen 16 - Swish Nicholson Cubs (39.21) - 84
7 - Bob Feller Cleveland (38.65) - 100 22 - Claude Passeau Cubs (27.87) - 77 23 - Phil Cavarretta Cubs (29.79) -75 17 - Dixie Walker Brooklyn (35.15)- 84
8 -  Dominic DiMaggio Boston (24.73) - 98 29 - Mort Cooper Cards (28.6) - 74 26 - Rudy York Detroit (24.06) - 75 18 - Johnny Hopp Pittsburgh (19.75) -83
9 - Luke Appling Chicago (40.76) - 97 30 - Kirby Higbe Brooklyn (18.55) - 74 27 - Johnny Mize Cards (41.1) - 74 24 - Vince DiMaggio Pittsburgh (12.79) - 75
10 - Pee Wee Reese Brooklyn (33.68) - 93 34 - Allie Reynolds  Yankees (12.76) - 71 36 - George McQuinn Yankees (16.88) - 68 25 - Jeff Heath Cleveland (30.5) - 75
11 - Marty Marion Cards (30.7) - 92 37 - Hank Borowy Yankees (16.57) - 68 39- Frank McCormick Reds (26.33) - 67 28 - Country Slaughter Cards (32.77) - 74
12 - Bucky Walters Reds (28.59) - 92 38 - Harry Brecheen Cards (32.68) - 68 45 - Mickey Vernon Washington (12.92) - 64 31 - George Case Washington  (11.51) - 73
13 - Dutch Leonard Washington (31.84) - 89 42 - Johnny Van Der Meer Reds (23.63) - 66 Hank Greenberg Pirates (20.35) - 40 32 - Roy Cullenbine Detroit (31.72) - 72
13 - Joe Gordon Cleveland (45.64) - 88 50 - Johnny Sain Braves (18.04) - 60 33 - Stan  Spence Washington (22.34) - 72
14 - Bob Elliott Pittsburgh (39.67) - 86 Spud Chandler Yankees (18.87) - 58 Top Second Basemen 35 - Charlie Keller Yankees (37.28) - 68
15 - Tommy Holmes Braves (32.77) - 85 Eddie Lopat Yankees (15.35) - 58 13 - Joe Gordon Cleveland (45.64) - 88 41- Mel Ott Giants (27.68) - 66
16 - Swish Nicholson Cubs (39.21) - 84 Bobo Newsom Washington (23.26) - 58 20 - Bobby Doerr Boston (41.71) - 82 44 - Pete Reiser Brooklyn (21.06)  - 65
17 - Dixie Walker Brooklyn (35.15)- 84 Tex Hughson Boston (25.61) - 57 Snuffy Stirnweiss Yankees (27.7) - 59 47 - Wally Moses A's (19.19) - 63
18 - Johnny Hopp Pittsburgh (19.75) -83 Tiny Bonham Yankees (24.53) - 56 Eddie Stanky Brooklyn (25.04) - 37 48 - Tommy Henrich Yankees (27.46) - 62
19 - Rip Sewell Pittburgh (25.12) - 83 Virgil Trucks Detroit (22.17) - 54 49 - Jim Russell Pittsburgh (16.27) - 62
20 - Bobby Doerr Boston (41.71) - 82 Paul Derringer Reds (10.55) - 53 Top Shortstops  Indian Bob Johnson Boston (24.21) - 58
21 - Dizzy Trout Detroit  (37.62) - 79 Joe Dobson Boston (17.54) - 53 1 - Lou Boudreau Cleveland (59.86) - 114  Ralph Kiner Pirates (25.3) - 50
22 - Claude Passeau Cubs (27.87) - 77 Howie Pollett Cards (24.13) - 51 6 - Vern Stephens Browns (35.16) - 101  
23 - Phil Cavarretta Cubs (29.79) -75 Schoolboy Rowe Phillies (18.91) - 50 9 - Luke Appling Chicago (40.76) - 97  
24 - Vince DiMaggio Pittsburgh (12.79) - 75 Warren Spahn Braves (20.33) - 48 10 - Pee Wee Reese Brooklyn (33.68) - 93
25 - Jeff Heath Cleveland (30.5) - 75 Max Lanier Cards (21.06) - 45 11 - Marty Marion Cards (30.7) - 92
26 - Rudy York Detroit (24.06) - 75 Nels Potter Browns (24.54) - 42 40 - Phil Rizzuto Yankees (20.63) - 67
27 - Johnny Mize Cards (41.1) - 74 Preacher Roe Pirates (20.39) - 30 Johnny Pesky Boston (23.64) - 59
28 - Country Slaughter Cards (32.77) - 74
29 - Mort Cooper Cards (28.6) - 74 Top Relief Pitchers Top Third Basemen
30 - Kirby Higbe Brooklyn (18.55) - 74 Joe Page Yankees (7.59) -   37 14 - Bob Elliott Pittsburgh (39.67) - 86
31 - George Case Washington  (11.51) - 73 Joe Haynes Chicago (10.05) -    35 46 - Stan Hack Cubs (31.54) - 63
32 - Roy Cullenbine Detroit (31.72) - 72 Ace Adams Giants (7.05) -   23 Ken Keltner Cleveland (27.34) - 59
33 - Stan  Spence Washington (22.34) - 72 Joe Beggs Reds (10.34) -    23 Whitey Kurowski Cards (23.98) - 53
34 - Allie Reynolds  Yankees (12.76) - 71 Ted Wilks Cards (13.83) -    20
35 - Charlie Keller Yankees (37.28) - 68 Johnny Murphy Yankees (6.09) -   19
36 - George McQuinn Yankees (16.88) - 68 Satchell Paige Cleveland (3.27) -    3
37 - Hank Borowy Yankees (16.57) - 68
38 - Harry Brecheen Cards (32.68) - 68
39- Frank McCormick Reds (26.33) - 67
40 - Phil Rizzuto Yankees (20.63) - 67
41- Mel Ott Giants (27.68) - 66
42 - Johnny Van Der Meer Reds (23.63) - 66
43 - Walker Cooper Cards (19.08) - 65
44 - Pete Reiser Brooklyn (21.06)  - 65
45 - Mickey Vernon Washington (12.92) - 64
46 - Stan Hack Cubs (31.54) - 63
47 - Wally Moses A's (19.19) - 63
48 - Tommy Henrich Yankees (27.46) - 62
49 - Jim Russell Pittsburgh (16.27) - 62
50 - Johnny Sain Braves (18.04) - 60